The U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans.
The U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans. Cheryl Gerber for The Texas Tribune

The Obama administration on Thursday filed notice that it will appeal a Texas federal judge’s ruling that temporarily blocked new federal guidelines directing public schools to accommodate transgender students, including allowing them to use bathrooms that align with their gender identity.ย 

Federal officials say they will ask the U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals to overturn an injunction issued by Fort Worth-based U.S. District Judge Reed O’Connor. On Tuesday, O’Connor reaffirmed that his ruling blocking the guidelines applied nationwide, not just in the 13 states that filed suit against the federal government.ย 

O’Connor issued the original ruling in August on the same day millions of Texas children headed back to school, preventing the federal government from enforcing the guidelines as the case went through the courts.ย 

In a 38-page order, Oโ€™Connor sided with Texas and 12 other states challenging the federal directive, saying the โ€œstatus quoโ€ should remain in place nationwide until the court rules on the case or a federal appeals court provides further guidance because theย administration had not followed proper rule-making procedure in crafting the guidelines.

Oโ€™Connor did not, however, rule on the merits of the case, noting โ€œthe resolution of this difficult policy decision is not … the subject of this order.โ€

The legal fight stems from guidelines issued in early May by the Obama administration in which it noted that discrimination against transgender students violatesย Title IX, a federal statuteย prohibiting discrimination based on sex at institutions that receive federal funding.ย Those protections, the administrationย said, extend to gender identity and give transgender students the right to use their preferred bathrooms in public schools.ย While the guidelines do not have the force of law, school districts could risk losing federal money if they do not comply.

Citing privacy and safety concerns surrounding the use of student bathrooms, lockers and other facilities, Texas Attorney Generalย Ken Paxtonย moved quickly to challengeย the guidelines in court.ย In their original legal complaint โ€” filed on behalf of the tiny Harrold Independent School District โ€” state attorneys argued that Title IXย explicitly prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex butย not gender identity.

The lawsuit is part of a national fight that has erupted around the issue of rights for transgender individuals.ย Non-discrimination protections for gay and transgender residents are not new; many municipalities have hadย policies on the booksย for years. But the fight flared upย in Texas earlier this year after Fort Worth ISDย approved its own policyย to accommodate transgender students.

Texas is also leading a suit against the federal government over a regulation prohibiting discrimination against transgender individuals in some health programs.

Read related Tribune coverage:

  • Walnut Springs Elementary School’s decision to allow a transgender student, born a boy, to use girls’ bathrooms sparked contentious debate during a Monday night meeting of the Dripping Springs School Board.

  • Ramping up its fight over the rights of transgender people, Texas filed a lawsuit Tuesday against the federal government over a regulation prohibiting discrimination against transgender individuals in some health program.
  • A federal judge in Fort Worth has blocked Obama administration guidelines directing the nationโ€™s public schools to allow transgender students to use bathrooms and other facilities that align with their gender identity.

Alexa Ura reported for The Texas Tribune from 2013 to 2023. She covered the complex dynamics of race, ethnicity, wealth, poverty and power and how they are shaping the future of Texas and Texans, in the...