BY ANGELA BAUER

Executive Vice President for Academic Affairs and Provost

Higher education is currently gripped by an existential debate over artificial intelligence, one that is currently playing out nationwide at governing board meetings, across news headlines, and in social media feeds.  At times, these conversations devolve into a rigid binary: either ban AI to protect academic integrity or embrace AI wholesale to stay relevant.

The polarization is understandable. Unlike previous technologies that enhanced our access to information, AI can perform tasks that we once viewed as uniquely human – such as reasoning through problems, constructing arguments, and generating original text. As a result, AI is forcing higher education to rethink the nature of learning, what constitutes mastery, and the evolving role of the professor.

 Academic leaders have a fundamental responsibility to confront these existential questions head on, rather than letting the debate polarize us. The real world does not operate in binaries, and neither can our classrooms. Preparing Texas students for an AI-integrated workforce requires us to move beyond false choices and embrace the complexity of this moment.

Embracing complexity means recognizing that both extreme views are wrong – and right – at the same time. There are times when learning must occur in an explicitly “AI-free” space. Building cognitive muscle, developing a unique voice, and mastering foundational logic require unassisted human effort. Just as a runner cannot build endurance riding in a golf cart, a student cannot develop critical thinking skills by letting a machine do the heavy lifting.

At the same time, there are disciplines and professions where AI fluency is no longer optional but rather is fundamental. In business, healthcare, and graphic arts, for example, AI is rapidly altering how work gets done. A recent Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas study highlighted how generative AI is shifting the entry level job market for college graduates, automating routine tasks and raising the bar on what employers will expect on day one. If we send our graduates into the workforce without practical and ethical AI literacy, we are failing them.

At Texas Woman’s University, we have trusted our experts – namely, our faculty – to develop an AI roadmap for our students. Rather than giving top-down system mandates, we have empowered faculty within their specific disciplines to determine where AI belongs and where it does not. An English professor might require pen-and-paper drafts for a personal reflection, while a nursing or business professor might integrate AI tools to analyze clinical data or develop marketing strategies. This nuanced approach honors academic rigor and disciplinary expertise.

We have equipped our faculty with both the autonomy and the resources to navigate these decisions, because we know how much is at stake for our students. As AI reshapes the economy, a digital divide is emerging; students with prior access or experience with technology gain AI fluency informally, while first generation students risk falling behind.

Closing this literacy gap is central to our mission. If we do not teach our students how to use AI tools critically, ethically and strategically, we risk leaving them behind in the economy we are preparing them to lead.

This issue extends far beyond the job market. As statewide and national debates continue about policy guardrails around digital safety, data privacy, and automated decision-making, society desperately needs an educated citizenry that understands technology.  Policies alone are not enough; we need voters, professionals, and community leaders who understand how these models function, how to apply the technology ethically, and their potential impact on human health and the environment.

As an academic year gets underway across Texas, let us move past the polarization. AI is not going to replace the human element of higher education, but it is challenging us to refine it. That will require that we move past false binaries and lean into the complexity, ensuring that our students not only survive the “AI moment,” but that they lead it.

Angela Bauer is the executive vice president for academic affairs and provost at Texas Woman’s University.