Skip to main content

Liveblog: Cruz and Dewhurst in Third GOP Runoff Debate in Houston

On the first day of early voting in the July 31 primary runoffs, Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst and former Texas Solicitor General Ted Cruz took part in their final televised debate of the election cycle. It wasn't your usual debate.

Ted Cruz and Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst at a U.S. Senate debate in Houston on July 23, 2012.

HOUSTON - An unusual format made for a unusual debate Monday evening in Houston.

On the first day of early voting in the July 31 primary runoffs, Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst and former Texas Solicitor General Ted Cruz participated in their third televised debate of the runoff in an hourlong event hosted by King Street Patriots and Fox 26, a Houston affiliate.

In front of an audience of more than 350 people, the candidates answered about a dozen questions, all of which came from voters in the room or via social media.

Neither candidate was permitted to rebut his opponent’s remarks, creating a situation in which both Dewhurst and Cruz freely attacked one other but found few chances to defend themselves.

Though attendees were told in advance to refrain from audibly responding to either of the candidates during the debate, one attendee yelled, “Liar” and another shouted, “Not true” at different points. The candidates ignored them.

At one point, Cruz accused Dewhurst of “maligning” Cruz’s patriotism with ads about Cruz’s work as an appellate lawyer for a Chinese tire manufacturer. Dewhurst denied that, prompting Cruz to briefly break the rules and challenge Dewhurst to explain what he meant by a mailer that featured Cruz’s face in front of a Chinese flag.

Dewhurst senior adviser Jim Bognet said after the debate that the Dewhurst campaign was questioning Cruz’s “judgment and values, not his patriotism."

This was the fifth televised event for Republicans Dewhurst and Cruz, after one debate and one candidate forum during the primary, each of which also featured other candidates, and two previous one-on-one debates during the runoff.

Both candidates plan to spend the week furiously campaigning across the state, trying to turn out their voters and using the influence of prominent Republicans to help them do it. Dewhurst voted early Monday morning in Austin alongside Gov. Rick Perry. Cruz will appear at a rally in Dallas with pundit Glenn Beck and former U.S. Rep. Dick Armey on Friday — the last day of early voting before the Tuesday, July 31 election.


by Aman Batheja
Tonight's event is open to the public. After opening statements, the candidates will spend the remainder of the debate answering questions posed by the moderaters, all of which will be taken from social media and members of the audience.
by Aman Batheja
Every seat at the debate hall is now taken. Organizers say there are approximately 387 people in the audience.
by Aman Batheja
Texas Conservatives Fund, a pro-Dewhurst Super PAC, has just released a new ad slamming Cruz on his legal work for a Pennsylvania developer involved in a judicial bribing scandal. Here's a link to the ad, which could come up in tonight's debate.
by Aman Batheja
Dewhurst and Cruz are now both on stage, each behind a podium. As Dewhurst walked on the stage, the crowd politely clapped. When they saw Cruz behind him, they cheered and stood up.
by Aman Batheja
Melinda Spaulding is the moderater of the debate. The panel is made up of Fox Houston reporter Sally MacDonald and King Street Patriot founder Catherine Engelbrecht.
by Aman Batheja
Spaulding just announced that candidates will not be allowed any time for rebuttals during the debate.
by Aman Batheja
In his opening statement, Cruz said he and his wife have had an incredible year criss-crossing the state visiting "“innumerable IHOPs and Denny’s and VFW halls.”

“We’re in this runoff because conservatives have united across the state of Texas,” Cruz said.

Working under Attorney General Greg Abbott, he says he successfully defended the Pledge of Allegiance, the 10 Commandments and U.S. soverignty.
by Aman Batheja
In his opening statement, Dewhurst reviewed his life story and listed his five priorities if elected.

If elected, Dewhurst said he would focus on repealing "Obamacare," bringing the Texas model of government in Washington, getting government “out of the way” of business, tripling the size of the border patrol and reinstating family values.

"Barack Obama is taking freedoms away from us," Dewhurst said.
by Aman Batheja
First question: what parts of "Obamacare" would the candidate keep in a "repeal and replace" strategy?

Both candidates said they would repeal all of President Obama's federal healthcare reform. Dewhurst said he wanted to replace it with free-market reforms.

Cruz repeated an earlier attack, accusing Dewhurst of saying that US has "inferior outcomes" to some socialized countries in Europe.

“that’s based on left wing studies and I also don’t think it’s the role of government to be micromanaging the outcomes” of private healthcare services, Cruz said.
by Aman Batheja
The candidates were asked how they would revive the space program and domestic energy production and make Texas more business-friendly?

Both candidates spoke about the need of getting government out of the way of the private sector. Both are also in favor of encouraging more domestic energy production.

Dewhurst ran out of time before he could address space exploration. Cruz said he strongly supports the space program and called space exploration “integral” to our defending the country.
by Aman Batheja
Someone in the audience just called out "Liar" while Cruz was speaking. It's unclear who the comment was directed at. Cruz was talking about Dewhurst removing a speech from his official website in which he said he supported a guest worker program. Dewhurst says he has never supported such a program before the border is secure.
by Aman Batheja
The candidates were asked a very simple question: "Why are they fighting so much?"

Cruz answered first.

“From day one, my campaign has kept the focus on the issues. What we’re talking about tonight is amnesty and payroll tax and the Lt. Gov’s record and my record," Cruz said. He said his father received a Dewhurst attack mailer in the mail that featured Cruz's head in front of a Chinese flag.

“I have to say Lt. Gov, you’re better than this…Do you stand by maligning my patriotism?” Cruz said.

Dewhurst said he was campaigning for Gov. Rick Perry’s presidential campaign in Iowa in early January when he learned the Club for Growth was running attack ads against him.

“From day one, since I got in this race, I have been running for United States Senate…since day one, my opponent has been running against me,” Dewhurst said.

“Not true,” a woman from the audience called. Dewhurst kept speaking. He said he and Cruz agree on "virtually every issue.

"You’re known by who you represent so when you choose to represent," Dewhurst said. He noted two of Cruz's clients that he often criticizes Cruz for taking on: a Chinese tire company found liable for stealing designs from an American company and a Pennsylvania developer accused of bribing judges.
by Aman Batheja
Dewhurst began an answer to a question to respond to Cruz’s allegation that Dewhurst has questioned Cruz’s patriotism.

“There’s no question you’re a strong patriot,” Dewhurst said.

“Why does your mailer say differently?” Cruz asked.

“It doesn’t say that Ted,” Dewhurst said. He offered to talk with Cruz about it later. Cruz asked why they couldn’t talk about it now. The debate moderator reminded the candidates that rebuttals were not going to be permitted. Dewhurst returned to answering the original question.
by Aman Batheja
Both candidates were asked about their positions on gun control. They both expressed sympathy for the victims of the recent movie theater shooting in Colorado. They also agreed that the tragedy should not be used as an excuse to strip Americans of their second amendment rights.

Cruz spoke about his work on a second amendment case before the U.S . Supreme Court and his receiving an award from the NRA in 2010.

Dewhurst said he had been endorsed by the NRA.

“The NRA has not endorsed you,” Cruz said.

“I stand corrected,” Dewhurst said. “You are absolutely right. The local people, the local people have.”
by Aman Batheja
The last question of the debate: What are the candidates' positions on the Castle Doctrine, a state law.

Both Cruz and Dewhurst praised the Castle Doctrine and, more broadly, the right of individuals to bear arms.
by Aman Batheja
The candidates each got 2:30 for closing arguments.
Echoing a Dewhurst line from earlier in the program, Cruz said, "“I very much agree with my opponent. We need doers."

He spoke about his work fighting for conservative causes before the Supreme Court.

We have seen conservatives all over the state of Texas to come together in this campaign," Cruz said. He listed several conservative leaders who have endorsed before running out of time.

Dewhurst said voters need to pick the candidate with the "character, values and judgment" to represent Texas.
“If Texas were as bad as my opponent keeps saying in these ads, Texas would look like California," Dewhurst said. "Texas is a good state. I'm proud of Texas."

Texans need truth. Help us report it.

Yes, I'll donate today

Explore related story topics

2012 elections David Dewhurst Ted Cruz