Texas House Democrat kills bill to allow smaller homes on smaller lots

Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.

---

A proposal to allow smaller homes on smaller lots in Texas cities — part of a slew of bills intended to tame the state’s high home prices and rents — died by a procedural move in the Texas House Sunday.

Senate Bill 15 — a top priority of Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who leads the Senate — would have reduced the amount of land cities require for single-family homes in new subdivisions. That would give homebuilders the flexibility to build smaller homes on less land, reducing the final cost of the home.

Some city officials as well as neighborhood activists who oppose new housing balked at the idea, arguing the proposal would be an undue incursion on cities’ ability to say what kinds of housing can be built and where.

The bill included narrow language designed to prevent it from taking effect within a mile of a police training center in Dallas County. Rep. Ramon Romero Jr., D-Fort Worth, raised the proposal to kill the bill, stating that language was out-of-bounds. The proposal was upheld, preventing the House from further discussing the bill.

Romero, a former member of Fort Worth’s city planning and zoning boards, said he wasn’t comfortable with the state weighing in on local rules that say how much land single-family homes must sit on. He also had concerns about whether homes allowed under the bill would create nuisances, such as runoff and traffic, for existing residents.

Romero, who owns a business that does residential masonry work, said he also wasn’t convinced that the bill would result in lower home prices, pointing to pricier homes built in recent years on smaller lots in Austin.

“It's already been proven that just because you have smaller (homes) does not immediately equate to more affordable (homes),” Romero said in an interview. “So if the argument is that that's what it is, then I'd say, show it to me.”

Allowing smaller homes on less land in Texas has generally been associated with lower home prices. Beginning in the late ‘90s, Houston reduced how much land the city requires single-family homes to sit on. Those reforms resulted in tens of thousands of new homes built on smaller lots, and housing advocates and researchers have credited that building boom with helping to keep the city’s home prices in check, especially when compared to other major U.S cities. Those homes tended to have lower values than traditional single-family homes on larger lots, research from New York University’s Furman Center for Real Estate and Urban Policy shows.

State Rep. Gary Gates, a Richmond Republican who carried the bill in the House, said he’s looking for ways to resurrect the proposal.

For example, it’s possible the proposal could find new life by being attached to another bill. But doing so would be difficult given that the legislative session ends June 2.

The bill sought to reduce the ultimate cost of a home by reducing how much land homebuyers would be required to purchase. Building smaller homes on smaller lots would also allow more homes to be built overall — chipping away at the state’s housing shortage, a key driver of the state’s high housing costs, the bill’s proponents argued.

“When a single legislator kills a bill that would help Texans find an affordable place to live, it’s not just out of touch, it’s a slap in the face to hardworking families trying to stay afloat,” said Nicole Nosek, who chairs Texans for Reasonable Solutions, a group that has pushed several housing bills this session.

Major cities in Texas tend to require single-family homes to sit between 5,000 and 7,500 square feet of land, according to a Texas Tribune analysis. The bill would have barred cities from requiring homes in new subdivisions to sit on more than 1,400 square feet. That provision wouldn’t have applied in existing neighborhoods, and new subdivisions would have to sit on at least five acres of land.

Given higher home prices and high interest rates, reducing the amount of land is necessary to give would-be homebuyers a path to homeownership, Gates said.

“If you’re in a house that you bought a number of years ago, life looks good to you,” Gates said of the bill’s opponents. “We don’t live in that world anymore.”

The proposal is part of a package of GOP bills aimed at reining in the state’s high home prices and rents by allowing more homes to be built. Texas builds more homes than any other state but not enough to keep up with demand amid the state’s population boom.

The state needs 320,000 more homes than it has, according to an estimate by the housing advocacy group Up For Growth. As a result, home prices and rents have skyrocketed, housing advocates and experts say.

Lawmakers this year have advanced proposals aimed at reducing red tape and local regulations to let more homes be built. Legislators have pushed bills to allow apartments and mixed-use developments along retail and commercial corridors and additional dwelling units in the backyards of single-family homes.

They’ve also pushed legislation to make it harder for landowners to stop new homes from being built near them and to allow homebuilders to more quickly obtain city building permits. None of those bills has yet reached the governor’s desk.

House lawmakers are also expected to take up other housing affordability bills Sunday. Those bills aim to make it easier to convert vacant office buildings into residences and encourage the construction of smaller apartments. They also would bar cities from outlawing manufactured homes and relaxing rules in college towns that restrict how many unrelated adults can live in a home.

On Sunday, the Senate approved House Bill 24, a priority for House Speaker Dustin Burrows. It aims to make it more difficult for property owners to block new housing.

---

First round of TribFest speakers announced! Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist Maureen Dowd; U.S. Rep. Tony Gonzales, R-San Antonio; Fort Worth Mayor Mattie Parker; U.S. Sen. Adam Schiff, D-California; and U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett, D-Dallas are taking the stage Nov. 13–15 in Austin. Get your tickets today!