Sister of Uvalde shooting victim testifies before Texas lawmakers: “I’m terrified to go back” to school
Jazmin Cazares, 17, was one of several family members of shooting victims and experts testifying before Texas lawmakers on Thursday. Her sister, Jackie Cazares, 9, was one of the victims of the school shooting in Uvalde.
Sign up for The Brief, our daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.
With her voice shaking as she delivered testimony to lawmakers, Jazmin Cazares, the sister of Jackie Cazares, who was slain during a mass shooting last month at Robb Elementary in Uvalde, called for tighter background checks, red flag laws and for lawmakers to “do something” to prevent future mass shootings.
“This morning around 5:30 a.m. I sat on my sister’s bed and I cried, I cried and I cried,” she said. “[Then] I wiped my tears, got in my car and drove four hours to get here. I shouldn’t have to be here right now. I should be at home watching a movie with my sister — it’s summer.”
Cazares, 17, told lawmakers she was testifying in honor of her sister Jackie and her cousin Annabell Rodriguez, who was also killed by a gunman who took the lives of 19 children and two teachers. She called Jackie “one of the sweetest souls anyone will ever meet” who wanted to travel to Paris when she graduated from high school.
Cazares said her family was still in shock as they continue to learn details of the shooting, saying there are signs the gunman could have been stopped before he committed the massacre at the school.
“I’m here begging for you guys to do something,” Cazares said. “I’m here to honor Jackie, her friends, their families, my family and my community. You can honor them, too, by passing gun safety legislation.”
Cazares sat in the front row of the committee room with her mom, dad, uncle, aunt and cousin wearing shirts with an image of her sister Jackie portrayed as an angel. The meeting is the first joint hearing by the House committees on Homeland Security and Public Safety and Youth Health and Safety, which have been tasked with making recommendations for action the Legislature can take to address mass shootings. The hearing also included witness testimony from local law enforcement officers who urged the Legislature to pass gun restrictions like raising the age to buy a firearm.
Cazares said she has one year left of high school but is unsure whether she’ll return to school next year.
“I’m terrified for my life to go back,” she said. “I have senior year and that’s it. Am I going to survive it? It’s unbelievable. Absolutely unbelievable.”
Cazares said lawmakers should come together to pass red flag laws, which would allow local officials to take someone’s guns away if a judge declares them to be a danger, and said they could save lives. She also called for stricter background checks for gun sales.
“Background checks are needed to protect innocent communities like mine from being in danger by people who are unstable and signal that they are threats,” she said.
After her testimony, Cazares said in an interview with reporters,"I hope they listen. I hope they change something."
"I think people knowing that I lost someone, knowing that it hits so close to home, and other than the survivors I'm the closest thing they're going to get to those kids," she said, adding she believed they were listening to her plea. "I think they realize that. It's coming from me. I was directly affected."
Cazares, who said she plans to continue advocating for gun safety measures, said her family had not been invited to speak in front of other lawmaker panels. The Senate committee in charge of the response to the Uvalde shooting met twice this week.
She also said her family had not heard from Gov. Greg Abbott since the day after the shooting.
"We talked to him the day after and he seemed genuine, as well, but like you can fake being genuine," she said.
Abbott and other Texas Republican leaders have so far showed resistance to gun restriction measures, opting to pursue efforts to harden schools and increase resources for mental health.
Outside the committee room, her father Javier Cazares, was critical of the law enforcement response to the shooting and the release of inaccurate information to the public.
"We went to the press conference and they painted a pretty picture that they went in quick and swiftly and took the subject out," he said. "Later on, they said it took about 35, 45 minutes in that scene. Well, that's not a quick. It should have been over in five minutes or less."
"I don't believe anything they say," he added. "Nobody wants to get the blame for what their actions were that day. So yeah, they're gonna cover up. That's what they want. They don't want to give those body cam videos."
Javier Cazares said he supports the release of the police body cam videos from the scene because he wants to see the actions of police officers. But he said he does not want to see the carnage inside the classroom.
"As a father, I want to see," he said.
Cazares’ testimony was followed by that of shooting survivor and former state lawmaker Suzanna Hupp, who advocated against stricter background checks and other gun safety legislation. Hupp, whose parents were slain in a 1991 shooting at Luby’s cafeteria after she left her gun in her car for fear of losing her gun license, also pushed for the state to “end gun-free zones.”
Hupp became a gun rights advocate after the shooting that killed her parents and helped push for Texas to allow people to legally carry concealed weapons. She also served in the Legislature and continues to push for access to guns.
A group representing the Texas Police Chiefs Association told lawmakers they supported strengthening background checks for gun purchases and legislation that would raise the age for buying an assault rifle from 18 to 21.
"We believe in reasonable changes which include raising the age to 21 for these style weapons," said Stan Standridge, the police chief for the San Marcos Police Department.
The group also expressed support for bills aimed at creating a state criminal offense for "straw purchases," when someone buys a gun for someone who is barred from buying a gun. Straw purchases are a federal offense, but the police chiefs said it is rarely prosecuted by the feds.
The panel was also critical of the law enforcement response to the Uvalde shooting, saying law enforcement officers are taught protocols for such mass shooting incidents. Standridge said the officers responding to the incident did not appear to lack equipment, but had a "commitment issue" and another police chief said "incident command is maintained until relinquished."
Brian Hawthorne, the president of the Sheriff's Association of Texas, was also critical of the law enforcement response in Uvalde.
"There’s no doubt, the sheriff's association believes that police officers should have taken bullets, not children," said Hawthorne, the sheriff of Chambers County and a former DPS trooper.
The local law enforcement officials' recommendations to lawmakers were nearly identical to the recommendations it made two years ago when state leaders convened special committees to respond to the mass shootings in El Paso and Midland-Odessa in 2019. Those committees stopped their work when COVID-19 hit the U.S. in March 2020 and never issued the legislative recommendations they were tasked with providing before the 2021 legislative session.
Rep. Drew Darby, R-San Angelo, who led the special House committee and now sits on the new Youth Health and Safety Committee, apologized to the police panel for not making any progress since the last mass shootings that hit the state.
"I quite frankly am embarrassed that almost the same list that you provided in 2020 is intact and delivered in the same form to this committee than it was two years ago," Darby said. "We need to start checking some things off your list."
Join us Sept. 22-24 in person in downtown Austin for The Texas Tribune Festival and experience 100+ conversation events featuring big names you know and others you should from the worlds of politics, public policy, the media and tech — all curated by The Texas Tribune’s award-winning journalists. Buy tickets.
Your New Year’s resolution list isn’t complete without …
… supporting the Tribune. This new year, resolve to do your part to sustain trusted journalism in Texas. Join thousands of readers who power The Texas Tribune’s nonprofit newsroom.