Texas estimates it may owe feds $223 million after illegally decreasing special education funding
A major flaw in the way Texas spends money on kids with disabilities might lose the state almost a quarter of its annual special education grant.
Last October, Texas education officials told lawmakers they would likely owe the federal government $33 million for illegally decreasing funding for kids with disabilities. They reassured them it was a fraction — just 3% — of their federal special education grant and wouldn't hurt students.
Now, the state's estimate for how much it could owe has risen to $223 million, nearly a quarter of Texas' annual special education grant, officials confirmed to The Texas Tribune Friday. That total includes an estimated $111.6 million it may have to pay back for failing to spend it on kids with disabilities this fiscal year.
The U.S. Department of Education has found Texas in violation of a federal statute prohibiting states from reducing their funding for kids with disabilities from year to year, and warned the state that a financial penalty was coming. Now, advocates are concerned that Texas could lose an even bigger chunk of its funding, harming its efforts to overhaul special education for hundreds of thousands of students.
With seven weeks left in the legislative session, lawmakers could still spend the $111.6 million needed this year to avoid a federal penalty for 2019 — but the budget is well on its way to being decided.
"It's good that we're becoming aware of [these violations] now, even late during this legislative session, because there's an opportunity to amend the state budget to account for the loss of federal aid," said Steven Aleman, a lawyer and advocate at Disability Rights Texas. "But the opportunity to bring even some degree of resolution is closing. It would be best if the state could resolve the entire issue, because otherwise we will be in a perpetual situation of having to address shortfalls."
The Texas Education Agency said Friday that it is discussing solutions with the federal government and the Legislature.
"The primary objective of the discussions in progress is to ensure that special education services for students are not negatively impacted," said DeEtta Culbertson, a TEA spokesperson.
The issue is tied to a major flaw in the way Texas chooses to spend money on kids with disabilities. Texas "weights" its funding for kids with disabilities, paying schools more to educate kids who have more severe disabilities or need more personalized attention in the classroom. The state's lawyers unsuccessfully argued at the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals last year that it decreased spending on kids with disabilities in 2012 because students just didn't need services that cost as much.
A panel of Fifth Circuit judges bluntly opined in November that Texas' system "creates a perverse incentive for a state to escape its financial obligations merely by minimizing the special education needs of it students."
Earlier this week, Rep. Mary E. González, D-Clint, successfully added wording to a House school finance bill that would require the Texas education commissioner to shore up school district special education funding this school year.
"This amendment is one step in addressing the state's shortfall with respect to special education funding," Gonzalez told the Tribune Friday. "In order to ensure a complete process, we need to put more money towards our students who need special education services, and make sure that those who need services have access to them."
But getting the money to schools would also require additional appropriations. Any additional spending tweaks House lawmakers want to make must be ironed out in conference committee negotiations toward the end of the session, said the House's lead budget writer Rep. John Zerwas, R-Richmond.
In the last few years, Texas has continually fielded reprimands from the federal government for violation special education law. A federal investigation in 2018 found Texas in violation of effectively capping the percentage of students who could receive special education services.
Education officials say they have followed federal requirements to overhaul special education, allowing them to "improve the standard of service to students with disabilities across Texas."
Advocates worry any financial penalty would end up decreasing money given to schools for providing student services.
"The loss of federal aid because of the state's failure to spend at the appropriate level will directly affect agency operations and efforts to bring the state into compliance with the federal investigation, but more importantly would also affect the availability of services at the local level by putting even more of a burden on local tax dollars to pay for services," Aleman said. "Any shortfall in federal aid because of a state violation needs to be made up by the state."
Information about the authors
Quality journalism doesn't come free
Perhaps it goes without saying — but producing quality journalism isn't cheap. At a time when newsroom resources and revenue across the country are declining, The Texas Tribune remains committed to sustaining our mission: creating a more engaged and informed Texas with every story we cover, every event we convene and every newsletter we send. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on members to help keep our stories free and our events open to the public. Do you value our journalism? Show us with your support.Yes, I'll donate today