Skip to main content

Immigration shelters nationwide ordered to show minors disputed Texas booklet that links abortion to cancer

Four congressional Democrats objected to the pamphlet this week, saying it includes "blatant lies about the safety of abortion."

Pages from the state's proposed update to "A Woman's Right to Know" booklet

Once again, Texas is at the center of a dispute over how the federal government treats pregnant, undocumented minors in its custody.

Last fall, a Texas case made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court when local immigration officials refused to let an undocumented minor leave federal custody to have an abortion. Now, with that case still pending, a top federal immigration official has ordered that a Texas health department booklet containing dubious scientific claims about the dangers of abortion be disseminated to undocumented minors nationwide.

Last month, according to The Dallas Morning News, the Office of Refugee Resettlement instructed shelters across the country to provide minors in their custody with “A Woman’s Right to Know,” a booklet created by Texas health officials that features disputed health information, including claims that abortion has been linked to breast cancer and infertility. Medical experts have long disputed the contents of the pamphlet.

The booklet — which Texas abortion providers must show patients 24 hours before they undergo the procedure — also outlines gestational stages, abortion risks and alternative options, including adoption.

Four congressional Democrats objected this week to the government’s push to disseminate that pamphlet nationwide, both because of its “blatant lies about the safety of abortion” and because much of the information it contains is specific to Texas law. They also criticized Scott Lloyd, the director of the Office of Refugee Resettlement, for handing down “increasingly unhinged and unethical rules and procedures.”

“Mr. Lloyd has now made the caregivers of these young women – those to whom they look for support and nurturing – complicit in lying and spreading misinformation about their reproductive health,” wrote U.S. Reps. Jerrold Nadler of New York, Zoe Lofgren of California, Diana DeGette of Colorado and Barbara Lee of California.

Their criticism comes amid uncertainty about the rights of undocumented pregnant minors in the custody of federal immigration officials — a question rooted in Texas.

Last fall, a pregnant teenager detained in a Brownsville shelter, who is called Jane Doe in court documents, was prevented from having an abortion after immigration officials refused to let her leave her shelter for the procedure. After a weeks-long court fight, Doe had the abortion, but the federal government protested that she had misled them about the timing of the procedure, keeping them from appealing to the Supreme Court in time to prevent it from happening.

The case is now pending before the nation’s highest court, which has been asked to decide whether Doe should have been allowed to undergo the procedure before the government had a chance to appeal. That decision will set an important precedent for other young migrant women in similar situations.  

Lawyers for the American Civil Liberties Union told The Texas Tribune in the fall that there are several hundred undocumented pregnant teenagers in federal custody, though it’s not clear how many of them are seeking abortions.

Wait! We need your help.


Explore related story topics

Congress Courts Health care Immigration Politics Abortion