WASHINGTON โย The Houseย Homeland Security Committee voted to send a bill to the full U.S. House on Wednesdayย that aims to follow through on President Donald Trumpโs campaign promise of constructing a wall at the United States’ย southern border.ย
The bill from U.S. Rep.ย Michael McCaul, an Austin Republican and the committee’s chairman,ย includedย $10 billion toward building a wall. It passed out of committee on a party-line, 17-12 vote.
โWe will never successfully secure our homeland until we are capable of controlling who can lawfully enter our country,โ McCaul saidย in his opening statement.
McCaul and the five other members of the Texas delegation who sit on the committee played starring roles in the hearing, whichย was not without a few fireworks.ย
U.S. Rep. Filemon Vela, D-Brownsville, proposed a series of amendments he said aimed โto hold the president to his promiseโ made on the campaign trail. The suggested amendments were clearly made in jest and to put his Republican colleagues in the uncomfortable situation of voting against some of Trump’s trademark promises.ย
Velaโs first amendment defined the term โborder wall systemโ within the bill to include 19 different ways the president had described the wall during his campaign including “big and beautiful,โ โsee through,โ โreal,โ โnot a fence,โ โmade of rebar and steelโ and โaesthetically-pleasing and consistent with the general surrounding environment.โย ย
โI offer this amendment to provide the members of the committee the clearest picture to date of the conflicting and absurd vision that the President has for his wall,โ Vela said. โA vote for this amendment is a vote for Donald Trumpโs vision, a yes vote for this amendment is a vote for his big, beautiful wall. I will vote no on this amendment.โ
A separate Vela amendment would have required delaying the construction of the wall until Mexico agrees in writing to reimburse the United States for โall costs associated with the constructionโ of a border wall.
With a Republican majority on the committee, neither amendment was adopted.
Other Democrats on the committee proposed amendments to change the name of the bill to โTaking Americansโ Land to Build Trumpโs Wall Act of 2017โ and to eliminate the section of the bill authorizing the wall completely.
Vela, an open critic of the border wall, also raised concerns about the government using eminent domain, a process where the government can seize private land, to build the wall.ย
He proposed an amendment that would have required the Department of Homeland Security to formally tell Congress that exercising eminent domain to build the wall was necessary for homeland security and that there are no other alternatives. That amendment fell only one vote short of passing.
U.S. Rep. Will Hurd, R-Helotes, successfully amended the bill to add language asserting that the wall would not be built in areas where โnatural terrain, โnatural barriersโ or โremotenessโ would make it โineffective.โย
Hurdโs amendment passed with Republican support. Most Democrats voted no, arguing that it still authorized a wall to be built. U.S. Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, D-Houston, voted present.
โSince 2009, I have been saying that building a wall from sea to shining sea is the least effective and most expensive solution to border security,โ Hurd said. โThis is especially true in areas like Big Bend National Park, where rough terrain, natural barriers and remoteness of a location render a wall or other structure impractical and ineffective.โ
Both Hurdย and Jackson Lee raised concerns about protecting endangered wildlife along the border. Hurdโs amendment added a clause that would respect existing agreements between national parks and U.S. Customs and Border Protection with regards to preserving national parks such as Big Bend.
Jackson Lee said building a wall along the border wasย poorย use of the committeeโs time, talking often about domestic terrorism and DACA, an Obama-era immigration program that the Trump administration plans to shut down, throughout the hearing.
โI believe that what we are doing here today is a misdirection, a wrong journey, a failure to the American people,โ Jackson Lee said. She urged the committee โto look seriously at how we protect the American people at all of our borders.โ
U.S. Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, who has authored a similar piece of legislation, released a statement in support of the bill after the hearing.
โWe canโt expect law enforcement to curb illegal immigration without equipping them with the tools they need to secure our border,โย Cornyn said.ย โI commend the Committee for taking this critical first step, and I look forward to continuing my work with Chairman McCaul to advance our border security solution.โ


