Texas House panel considers "private school choice" for kids with disabilities
House Bill 1335 by Rep. Ron Simmons would give students with disabilities online accounts of state money to use for private school tuition and certain homeschooling expenses, such as textbooks and curricula.
To many in the room, much of the discussion on whether Texas should subsidize private school tuition for some students with disabilities probably felt like a repeat.
Activists, educators and parents stayed past midnight on Friday morning to give their thoughts on why the House Public Education Committee should or should not pass its own version of a "private school choice" bill, proposed by Rep. Ron Simmons, R-Carrollton. Some of those who testified had shown up months ago for similar arguments in front of a Senate panel.
Under House Bill 1335, students who would qualify — those whose families have incomes below $200,000 — would get about $7,000 per school year. That would not cover the total cost of most schools, Simmons said.
"Sometimes a school can be doing the very best they can, but for that particular child, it just doesn't work," Simmons said. He recalled sending his son Daniel, who is on the autism spectrum, to a private Christian school with a small program dedicated to students with special needs. "When we stepped out of the car that night, he said, 'I finally have a team.'"
Early figures estimated Simmons' bill would cost $64 million to $211 million over the next two years, depending on the payment schedule to students, according to the Legislative Budget Board. An amended version of the bill put before the committee on Thursday is reduced in scope and limited in eligibility requirements and would cost much less, budget board staffers said.
Dozens of people stayed late Thursday to testify. Critics argued it would not hold private schools accountable for providing services to students with disabilities.
Dana Johnson, the special education director for Johnson City ISD, expressed concern that private providers are not held to the same state and federal standards as public schools for special education services. "Parents need to realize that at least they have a legal recourse in public settings. That's not the case in private schools," she said.
Simmons responded that parents know their children better than educators. He said parents provide accountability for private schools by deciding whether to keep their children enrolled.
Others argued HB 1335 would eventually lead to the expansion of voucher-type programs to include more than just students with disabilities.
"It is unfortunate that what seems to be a bill to assist students with special needs has ulterior motives and special consequences," said Ginger Russell, representing Texans for Homeschool Freedom, a group of homeschoolers fighting against private school choice. "Opening this up brings regulations and ramifications to the homeschooling community that we do not have right now and we don't want."
Several parents testifying in favor of the bill told legislators about their children’s struggles in public schools that did not understand how to provide needed special education services. Those parents said they found smaller class sizes and more specialized attention in smaller private schools. (Both the House and Senate will soon hear bills that would stop the state from capping the number of students who receive special education services — a response to an investigation into an alleged policy that the Texas Education Agency has repeatedly denied exists.)
Some of HB 1335's language mirrors the major "private school choice" bill the Senate passed in late March — one of Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick's top priorities this session. That bill, Senate Bill 3, would create an education savings account program, as one of two programs to subsidize private school tuition, for low-income students and all students with disabilities.
The House Public Education Committee has not taken up SB 3, and committee Chairman Dan Huberty, R-Houston, has previously said the issue is dead in the lower chamber.
He joined a whopping 102 other members of the House in voting for an amendment to the Senate budget that would prevent any money from being spent for private school tuition subsidies.
HB 1335 was left pending in committee early Friday morning.
Read related Tribune coverage:
- The Senate voted 18-13 Thursday to pass a major private school choice bill, creating two public programs that would subsidize private school tuition.
- Top House education official Dan Huberty has said private school choice is dead in the House. Representatives showed they overwhelmingly support that sentiment, in a 103-44 budget amendment vote.
Information about the authors
Quality journalism doesn't come free
Perhaps it goes without saying — but producing quality journalism isn't cheap. At a time when newsroom resources and revenue across the country are declining, The Texas Tribune remains committed to sustaining our mission: creating a more engaged and informed Texas with every story we cover, every event we convene and every newsletter we send. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on members to help keep our stories free and our events open to the public. Do you value our journalism? Show us with your support.Yes, I'll donate today