Illustration by Todd Wiseman / Jay Root

When lawmakers gave Comptroller Susan Combs more power to spend tax money to attract sporting events and conventions to the state, the idea was to generate economic development in Texas that might go somewhere else.

But in recent years Combs has used that power to approve millions of dollars in expenditures on events that originated here and don’t appear to be leaving Texas anytime soon.

Over the last two years, Combs, a Republican, has signed off on spending $2 million in state tax money to help defray the costs of the Cotton Bowl, a postseason college football game held in the Dallas-Fort Worth area since 1937; $1.5 million to help finance the Alamo Bowl college football games, played in San Antonio since its inception in 1993; and $2 million to stage two NASCAR auto races — the AAA Texas 500 and the Samsung Mobile 500 — that were specifically designed for Texas Motor Speedway in Fort Worth.

Several horse associations in Fort Worth and Amarillo have also used such funds to defray costs of events held in those cities year after year — funds that went directly to the private associations hosting the shows, officials say.

Combs’ office says the event fund expenditures, which hit an all-time high of $78 million last year, are authorized by the Legislature and supported by the cities in which events are being held. The cities also say the fund has been an invaluable tool in attracting and retaining marquee events.

 

The money used to lure such events comes from several “trust fund” accounts designed to bring out-of-state visitors to Texas. The accounts are fattened with sales, alcohol and hotel occupancy taxes that the events bring in from people traveling to Texas. Local governments or nonprofits they authorize must approve the eligible projects, and the cities hosting them are required to chip in some of their own tax receipts into the fund.

Critics are raising questions about whether such payouts violate at least the spirit of the economic development overhaul that was passed in 2009.

“Looking at some of those events, clearly they already would have been here already, so why are we spending tax dollars to bring them here?” said Texas Land Commissioner Jerry Patterson, a Republican who has repeatedly questioned Combs’ oversight of the tax incentive funding. “Is this Susan Combs’ slush fund? We need to know that. And who is doing the oversight?” (Patterson has been a frequent critic of Combs, whom he might face in a race for lieutenant governor in 2014).

The biggest rub is whether the location of events like the Cotton Bowl, inextricably linked to Texas, were truly subjected to a “highly competitive” process that involved cities in other states. That’s what the law requires.

Robert Wood, who oversees the program at the comptroller’s office, said that there are no set standards and that the state agency relies exclusively on what the local governmental entities tell him.

“The statute doesn’t specify what that highly competitive process is. The Legislature didn’t lay that out. Our role as the administrator is to simply, to the extent we can, say there was one,” Wood said. “And since we’re not involved in that part, what we basically rely on is that local organizing committee or the city or county to tell us that there was a highly competitive process involved.”

In the case of the Cotton Bowl, for example, Wood provided 2010 and 2011 letters from the city of Arlington, the Southeastern Conference and the Big 12 Conference all affirming that the North Texas region — where the bowl game has been held for more than seven decades — had been chosen through a “highly competitive selection process.”

But they are essentially form letters that use identical language each year, and they don’t mention the other cities that were considered or go into any detail about the process used. The strikingly similar letters from the SEC and Big 12 — which each field teams in the yearly game — differ only in the descriptions of their respective conferences, and otherwise use identical passages — the provenance of which could not be determined. (See the embedded documents below.)

Big 12 spokesman Bob Burda knew nothing of the letters and couldn’t comment, and the SEC did not return a phone message left by the Tribune.

Wood said the teams that play in the bowls could conceivably pick another venue outside Texas. He said the qualification for funding was based on the fact that teams from two national leagues brought in out-of-state fans to a Texas stadium. It’s not up to the comptroller’s office, he said, to truth-test claims that a bonafide competition over the site’s selection actually took place.

“It’s not up to me to believe or not to believe,” Wood said.

But Sen. Kirk Watson, D-Austin, author of the 2009 legislation, said he was concerned that the comptroller’s office appears to be allowing “the people who want the money to define ‘highly competitive.’ ” He also said the ever-increasing amount of the expenditures raises questions about whether the proper oversight is in place.

“What I intended to do is give the comptroller the flexibility to draft a program in an appropriate way,” Watson said. “It may be that the Legislature needs to look at it to make sure it is being properly administered.”

Combs has already come under fire for her handling of tax incentives dangled before the promoters of a Formula 1 auto race in Austin. After a ruckus was raised over her 2010 vow to provide $25 million a year in funding for the project, Combs backed away and said she wants to see how the first race goes next November.

In the last decade, the comptroller’s office has used the funding mechanism to help the lure the Super Bowl (to Houston in 2004 and Dallas in 2011), NCAA Final Four basketball tournaments, swimming championships and various all-star games.

Those are the type of “unique, one of a kind” events that were envisioned by the legislation that passed in 2009, according to a state House analysis of the bill.

But since the law went on the books in September of 2009, expenditures from the fund have risen dramatically — from $5.7 million the year the bill passed to $78 million in fiscal 2011. And the program has been used to attract far less unique events, like the Association of Kentucky Fried Chicken Franchisees, lured to San Antonio with the help of  $255,215 in tax incentives, and the International Convention of Alcoholic Anonymous, also held in San Antonio, for which the comptroller approved spending $4.5 million.

All told, the various funds, including the Major Events Trust Fund, the Events Trust Fund and their precursor programs have awarded $201 million since 2004, which includes the city’s portion, records show.

Every event, and each city, uses the funds in various ways. In some cases the money goes to defray the cost of security, emergency preparedness and event advertising. Some entities also use the money to upgrade their facilities.

But the statute is generous and broad, allowing for reimbursement of “costs relating to the preparations necessary or desirable for the conduct of the event and the payment of costs of conducting the event.”

And in many cases, the private entities hosting the events end up getting the money. In Fort Worth, for example, the comptroller has approved millions of dollars in state tax funding for shows put on by the National Cutting Horse Association, the American Paint Horse Association (both based in Fort Worth) and other equestrian groups.

In every case with the horse associations, the state’s share of the tax revenue went to the associations, used largely to pay out show prizes and increase their attractiveness to visitors, according to city convention officials.

Kirk Slaughter, Fort Worth’s public events director, acknowledged that in many cases the associations are receiving funding to promote shows they have always held in the city. But he said his counterparts in other cities around the country would love to steal them away.

“There is no doubt that the trust fund is a very, very powerful tool for keeping some of the major events here in the state of Texas. It gives us a competitive edge over some of these other states,” Slaughter said. “It keeps that spending coming here instead of the spending going to Tulsa or to Las Vegas.”

Becca Aaronson created the interactive graphic for this story.

// <![CDATA[ DV.load(‘http://www.documentcloud.org/documents/324817-cotton-bowl-2010-amp-2011.js’, { width: 635, height: 500, sidebar: false, text: false, container: “#DV-viewer-324817-cotton-bowl-2010-amp-2011″ }); var chart; var colors = Highcharts.getOptions().colors, categories = [‘2004’, ‘2005’, ‘2006’, ‘2007’, ‘2008’, ‘2009’, ‘2010’, ‘2011’, ‘2012’], name = ‘2004’, data = [{ y: 19348800, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2004’, categories: [‘Major League Baseball (MLB) All Star Game 2004’, ‘National Football League (NFL) Super Bowl XXXVIII (2004)’, ‘NCAA Men’s Division I Final Four Basketball Tournament 2004’], data: [4848800, 8700000, 5800000], color: ‘#B12125’ }}, { y: 0, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2005’, categories: [”], data: [0], color: ‘#3E67B0’ }}, { y: 7262278, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2006’, categories: [‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) World Championship Show 2006’, ‘Championship Car World Series – 2nd Round (Grand Prix of Houston – 2006)’, ‘National Basketball Association (NBA) All Star Game 2006’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Summer Spectacular 2006’], data: [238166, 1567000, 5040000, 417112], color: ‘#B12125’ }}, { y: 3148545, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2007’, categories: [‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) World Championship Show 2007’, ‘Appaloosa Horse Club (ApHC) World Championship Show 2006’, ‘Championship Car World Series – 3rd Round (Grand Prix of Houston – 2007)’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Futurity 2006’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Summer Spectacular 2007’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Super Stakes 2007’], data: [221524, 170139, 1782000, 459767, 178506, 336609], color: ‘#B12125’ }}, { y: 14138736, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2008’, categories: [‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) World Championship Show 2008’, ‘Appaloosa Horse Club (ApHC) World Championship Show 2007’, ‘Big 12 Conference Football Championship 2007’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Futurity 2007’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Summer Spectacular 2008’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Super Stakes 2008’, ‘NCAA Men’s Division I Basketball South Regional Tournament 2008’, ‘NCAA Men’s Division I Final Four Basketball Tournament 2008’], data: [369882, 69526, 551594, 614628, 266244, 518237, 4694375, 7054250], color: ‘#B12125’ }}, { y: 5665808, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2009’, categories: [‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) Fall Championship Show 2008’, ‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) World Championship Show 2009’, ‘Appaloosa Horse Club (ApHC) World Championship Show 2008’, ‘Latin Grammy Awards 2008’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Futurity 2008’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Summer Spectacular 2009’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Super Stakes 2009’, ‘NCAA Men’s and Women’s Indoor Track & Field Championships 2009’, ‘NCAA Men’s and Women’s Tennis Championships 2009’, ‘NCAA Men’s Baseball Regional Tournament 2009’, ‘NCAA Men’s Golf Regional 2009’, ‘NCAA Men’s Swimming and Diving Championships 2009’, ‘NCAA Women’s Division II Basketball Championships 2009’, ‘NCAA Women’s Swimming and Diving Championships 2009’, ‘Rock & Roll Marathon 2008’, ‘Texas vs. The Nation Football All Star Game 2009’, ‘Triton Financial Classic Professional Golfers’ Association (PGA) Champions Tour 2009′, ‘USA Taekwondo Junior Olympic Championships 2009’, ‘USA Triathlon Longhorn Ironman 70.3 (2008)’], data: [211453, 542016, 115520, 533942, 697983, 315557, 506702, 91116, 54009, 36322, 41791, 58523, 144054, 41068, 844890, 632687, 138875, 374032, 285268], color: ‘#B12125’ }}, { y: 45084162, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2010’, categories: [‘American Association of Diabetes Educators 37th Annual Meeting (2010)’, ‘American Nephrology Nurses’ Association (ANNA) 41st National Symposium (2010)’, ‘American Paint Horse Association Fall 2009 and World 2010 Championship Shows’, ‘American Southwest Conference (ASC) Track & Field Championships 2010’, ‘American Telemedicine Association Annual Meeting and Exposition 2010’, ‘Appaloosa Horse Club (ApHC) World Championship Show 2009’, ‘Associated Professional Sleep Societies Annual Meeting 2010’, ‘Association for Behavior Analysis 36th Annual Convention (2010)’, ‘Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development (ASCD) Annual Conference 2010’, ‘Babe Ruth 13-Year-Old World Series 2010’, ‘Big 12 Conference Swimming and Diving Championships 2010’, ‘Dish Network Corporation Annual Team Summit 2010’, ‘Higher Education Users Group “Alliance 2010” Annual Meeting’, ‘International Basketball Federation (FIBA) Americas Under-18 Basketball Tournament for Men 2010’, ‘International Convention of Alcoholics Anonymous 2010’, ‘Kiteboard Racing World Championships 2010’, ‘Lawson Conference and User Exchange 2010’, ‘Lone Star Conference (LSC) Baseball Championships 2010’, ‘Major League Soccer (MLS) All Star Game 2010’, ‘National Anti-Corrosion Engineers (NACE) International Annual Conference 2010’, ‘National Basketball Association (NBA) All Star Game 2010’, ‘National Cattlemen’s Beef Association (NCBA) Annual Convention 2010’, ‘National Council of La Raza Annual Conference 2010’, ‘Three National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Events’, ‘National Institute of Governmental Purchasing (NIGP) 65th Annual Forum and Expo (2010)’, ‘National Reined Cow Horse Association (NRCHA) Celebration of Champions 2010’, ‘National Reining Breeders Classic (NRBC) Championship 2010’, ‘Eight NCAA Men’s and Women’s Sporting Events’, ‘Notre Dame vs. Washington State University Football Game 2009’, ‘Premier Baseball’s Freshman and Senior National Championships 2010’, ‘Quarter Midgets of America (QMA) Western Grands 2010’, ‘Rawl Cup International Junior High School Basketball Tournament 2010’, ‘Rock & Roll Marathon 2009’, ‘Southland Conference Baseball Tournament 2010’, ‘Stag Parkway Business Solutions Tradeshow 2010’, ‘Sun Belt Conference (SBC) Men’s and Women’s Outdoor Track and Field Championships 2010’, ‘Texas vs. The Nation Football All Star Game 2010’, ‘U.S. Paralympics Spring Swimming Championships/Spring CanAm 2010’, ‘United States Bowling Congress (USBC) Women’s Championships 2010’, ‘U.S. Tennis Association Boy’s Under 14 & Boy’s and Girl’s Team Championships 2010’, ‘USA / ASA Girls 16-and-Under Fast Pitch Softball National Championships 2010’, ‘USA Gymnastics Women’s Collegiate National Championships 2010’, ‘USA Junior Olympics Boys Volleyball Championships 2010’, ‘USA Triathlon Ironman Pro and Longhorn Ironman Championships 2010’, ‘World’s Best Technologies (WBT) Showcase 2010’], data: [ 853497, 235042, 282670, 9853, 392664, 106071, 1035709, 506224, 652040, 55119, 49380, 505360, 377187, 56239, 4469945, 78703, 355877, 17526, 914039, 814723, 15437420, 838952, 567428, 1610319, 214816, 195727, 223775, 8601684, 803302, 116374, 69008, 166910, 852604, 31027, 155950, 70064, 652499, 43265, 898146, 40687, 595168, 58058, 453869, 578229, 41013], color: ‘#B12125’ }}, { y: 78053988, color: ‘#3E67B0’, drilldown: { name: ‘2011’, categories: [ ‘6 Conferences, Conventions, Expos < $100,000 each’, ‘6 Conferences, Conventions, Expos $100,000 to $200,000 each’, ‘3 Conferences, Conventions, Expos $200,000 to $300,000 each’, ‘3 Conferences, Conventions, Expos $300,000 to $400,000 each’, ‘4 Conferences, Conventions, Expos $400,000 to $500,000 each’, ‘Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) Conference 2011’, ‘Professional Photographers of America Imaging USA Annual Convention 2011’, ‘Emergency Nurses Association (ENA) Annual Convention 2010’, ‘Association for Financial Professionals Annual Conference 2010’, ‘GameStop, Inc. Annual Convention 2010’, ‘Firestone Twin 275s Indy Racing League Race Weekend (2011)’, ‘Samsung Mobil 500 NASCAR Race Weekend (2011)’, ’14 Sporting Championships < $100,000 each’, ‘Southwestern Athletic Conference (SWAC) Basketball Championships 2011’, ‘Tournament of Roller Hockey Series Championships 2011’, ‘Appaloosa Horse Club (ApHC) World Championship Show 2010’, ‘USA Triathlon Ironman 70.3 Pro Championships 2011’, ‘USA Triathlon Ironman 70.3 Collegiate Championships 2010’, ‘National AAU Taekwondo Youth and Adult Championships 2011’, ‘National Reining Breeders Classic (NRBC) Championship 2011’, ‘USA Karate National Championships 2011’, ‘Conference USA (C-USA) Men’s and Women’s Basketball Championships 2011’, ‘USA Taekwondo US Open Championships 2011’, ‘Water Quality Association Conference 2011’, ‘USA Gymnastics (USAG) U.S. Trampoline and Tumbling Junior Olympics National Championships 2011’, ‘USA Volleyball U.S. Open Championships and Conference 2011’, ‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) Youth World Championship Show 2011’, ‘American Miniature Horse Association (AMHA) World Championship Show 2010’, ‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) Fall Championship Show 2010’, ‘3 National Cutting Horse Association Events’, ‘National Reined Cow Horse Association (NRCHA) Celebration of Champions 2011’, ‘National Reining Horse Association (NRHA) Cowtown Classic 2011’, ‘4 Annual Meetings, Summits, Sessions < $200,000 each’, ‘5 Annual Meetings, Summits, Sessions $200,000 to $500,000 each’, ‘National Conference of State Legislatures Annual Legislative Summit 2011’, ‘American Epilepsy Society Annual Meeting 2010’, ‘United States and Canadian Academy of Pathology (USCAP) 100th Annual Meeting (2011)’, ‘Society of Nuclear Medicine Annual Meeting 2011’, ‘American College of Gastroenterology Annual Scientific Meeting and Postgraduate Course 2010’, ‘Academy of Management Annual Meeting 2011’, ‘7 NCAA Men’s and Women’s Sporting Events’, ’12 Sporting Events <$60,000 each’, ‘USA Fencing Junior Olympics 2011’, ‘Davis Cup Quarterfinals 2011’, ‘Memorial Hermann Ironman Texas Event 2011’, ‘Ticket City (Dallas Football Classic) Bowl Game 2011’, ‘Rock & Roll Marathon 2010’, ‘Chick-fil-A Operators Seminar 2011’, ‘National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) Texas Versus the Nation College All Star Challenge Football Game 2011’, ‘Valero Alamo Bowl 2010’, ‘AT&T Cotton Bowl Classic 2011’, ‘Summer National Senior Games 2011’, ‘National Football League (NFL) Super Bowl XLV (2011)’], data: [ 499240, 877881, 732541, 969814, 1766524, 576047, 650687, 707186, 715214, 912296, 656493, 1176211, 663098, 148343, 150275, 166237, 196203, 199390, 203908, 231782, 235061, 266158, 268378, 354691, 502173, 666078, 117824, 159854, 231362, 1519320, 128722, 354090, 604868, 1942109, 534707, 556668, 616297, 758041, 965099, 1373467, 1518001, 310876, 234442, 300701, 380123, 411785, 692822, 282198, 219049, 844066, 962620, 2794016, 31154062], color: ‘#B12125’ }}, { y: 28437290, color: ‘#3E67B0’, dataLabels: { enabled: true, formatter: function(){ return this.name; } }, drilldown: { name: ‘2012’, categories: [‘2nd Annual Livestrong Assembly Annual Conference (2012)’, ‘AAA Texas 500 NASCAR Race Weekend (2011)’, ‘Access Intelligence 21st Annual Clean Gulf Conference and Exhibition (2011)’, ‘American Association of Equine Practitioners (AAEP) 57th Annual Convention 2011’, ‘American Bankers Association Annual Convention Business Expo and Directors’ Forum 2011′, ‘American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons Annual Scientific Conference 2012’, ‘American Football Coaches Association Annual Convention 2012’, ‘American Miniature Horse Association (AMHA) World Championship Show 2011’, ‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) Fall Championship Show 2011’, ‘American Paint Horse Association (APHA) Youth World Championship Show 2012’, ‘American Quarter Horse Association (AQHA) Adequan Select World Championship Show 2011’, ‘American Society of Agronomy, Crop Science Society of America, Soil Science Society of America International Annual Meeting 2011’, ‘American Volleyball Coaches Association Convention 2011’, ‘Annual AAU Junior Olympics 2012’, ‘Appaloosa Horse Club (ApHC) World Championship Show 2011’, ‘Association of Kentucky Fried Chicken Franchisees, Inc. Annual Convention 2012’, ‘Association of Military Surgeons of the United States Annual Meeting 2011’, ‘AT&T Cotton Bowl Classic 2012’, ‘Behavioral Science Technology (BST) Safety in Action Conference 2012’, ‘Big 12 Women’s Soccer Championships 2011’, ‘BoatUS Big Bass Bash Fishing Tournament 2012’, ‘Boston Scientific (CRM) Annual Sales Meeting 2012’, ‘Cowboys Classic Football Game 2011’, ‘Foundation of Flexographic Technical Association (FFTA) Annual Forum and INFO*FLEX Exhibition 2012’, ‘International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials Annual Education and Business Conference 2011’, ‘Ironman 70.3 U.S. Collegiate National Championships 2011’, ‘Junior Volleyball Association World Challenge 2012’, ‘Lone Star Conference Men’s and Women’s Basketball Championships 2012’, ‘Maccabi Games and ArtsFest 2012’, ‘MegaFest 2012’, ‘Microsoft Dynamics Convergence World Conference 2012’, ‘National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners 33rd Annual Conference 2012’, ‘National Association of Seed and Venture Funds Conference 2011’, ‘National Association of Tower Erectors Annual Conference 2012’, ‘National Collegiate Table Tennis Championships 2012’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Futurity 2011’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Summer Spectacular 2012’, ‘National Cutting Horse Association (NCHA) Super Stakes 2012’, ‘National Demolition Association Annual Conference 2012’, ‘National Guard FLW College Fishing Regional Championships 2011’, ‘National Reined Cow Horse Association (NRCHA) Celebration of Champions 2012’, ‘National School Supply & Equipment Association (NSSEA) 2011’, ‘NCAA Division I Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) Game 2012’, ‘NCAA Women’s Division II Basketball “Elite 8” 2012’, ‘NCAA Women’s Volleyball Championships 2011’, ‘North American Prospects Hockey League Tournament 2012’, ‘Offense Defense Sports and the O-D All-American Bowl 2011’, ‘Orthopedic Trauma Association Annual Meeting 2011’, ‘PennWell Corporation Distributech Conference and Exhibition 2012’, ‘Reichert Celebration 2011’, ‘Research Chefs Association Annual Conference and Culinology Expo 2012’, ‘Society of Exploration Geophysicists Annual Meeting 2011’, ‘Solar Power International Conference 2011’, ‘Southwest Athletic Conference (SWAC) Men’s and Women’s Basketball Championships 2012’, ‘Specialty Tools and Fasteners Distributors Association Annual Convention and Trade Show 2011’, ‘Stampin Up Annual Leadership Meeting 2012’, ‘Sweet Adelines International Convention 2011’, ‘The American Medical Directors Association Annual Symposium 2012’, ‘Ticket City Bowl Game 2012’, ‘U.S. Fencing Association North American Cup B Championships 2011’, ‘U.S. Youth Soccer Olympic Development Program (ODP) Championships 2012’, ‘U.S.A. Olympic Marathon Trials 2012’, ‘United States Australian Football League (USAFL) National Championships 2011’, ‘United States Geospatial Intelligence Foundation (GEOINT) Symposium 2011’, ‘University of Missouri School of Medicine Annual National Conference on Peritoneal Dialysis 2012’, ‘USA Football International Bowl 2012’, ‘USA Hockey Girls Tier II National Championships 2012’, ‘USA Triathlon Ironman 70.3 Pro Championships 2012’, ‘USA Wrestling Greco-Roman & Women’s Freestyle Championships 2012’, ‘Valero Alamo Bowl 2011’, ‘Veterans of Foreign Wars of the US (VFW) Annual National Convention 2011’], data: [36485, 862386, 147194, 805119, 210044, 288800, 723092, 95594, 164660, 65838, 46999, 328506, 168120, 2764226, 164558, 255215, 326322, 989728, 133442, 33112, 40689, 102028, 250000, 127418, 66439, 169744, 436310, 37119, 55135, 2274321, 307461, 148780, 15825, 140974, 33186, 1643744, 1343840, 1140024, 123710, 16167, 102005, 187352, 321552, 26823, 467682, 127517, 477590, 196289, 724184, 1021231, 118396, 806013, 320794, 132578, 547331, 121952, 459857, 194789, 521397, 134166, 31360, 1235786, 124387, 357103, 119916, 79385, 183545, 86642, 36123, 692061, 1399130], color: ‘#B12125’ }}]; function setChart(name, categories, data, color) { chart.xAxis[0].setCategories(categories); chart.series[0].remove(); chart.addSeries({ name: name, data: data, color: color || ‘white’ }); } chart = new Highcharts.Chart({ chart: { renderTo: ‘container’, type: ‘column’ }, title: { text: ‘Texas Comptroller’s Annual Events Trust Fund, 2004-2012’, style: { fontWeight: ‘bold’, color: ‘#000000’ } }, subtitle: { text: ‘Place cursor on columns for details. Click a column to view events from that year, click again to return.’, style: { color: ‘#000000’ } }, credits: { enabled: false }, xAxis: { categories: categories, labels: { enabled: false } }, yAxis: { title: { text: ‘Total Funding – State and Local Share’, style: { color: ‘#000000’ } }, labels: { formatter: function() { return ‘$’ + Highcharts.numberFormat(this.value, 0, ‘,’); } } }, legend: { enabled: false }, plotOptions: { column: { cursor: ‘pointer’, point: { events: { click: function() { var drilldown = this.drilldown; if (drilldown) { // drill down setChart(drilldown.name, drilldown.categories, drilldown.data, drilldown.color); } else { // restore setChart(name, categories, data); } } } }, dataLabels: { enabled: false } } }, tooltip: { formatter: function() { var point = this.point, s = this.x + ‘:$’ + Highcharts.numberFormat(this.y, 0, ‘,’) + ‘
‘; if (point.drilldown) { s += ‘Click to view funding for events in ‘ + point.category; } else { s += ‘Click to return to overview.’; } return s; } }, series: [{ name: name, data: data, color: ‘white’}], exporting: { enabled: false } });// ]]>

Texas Tribune donors or members may be quoted or mentioned in our stories, or may be the subject of them. For a complete list of contributors, click here.

Texans need the truth. Help us report it.

Become a member. Join today.

Choose an amount or learn more about membership.

Jay Root is an award-winning journalist who reported for the Tribune from 2011 to 2020. He covered the dramatic collapse of Gov. Rick Perry’s 2012 presidential campaign and went on to write an ebook...