House Drops Whitmire's Capitol Smoking Ban in Preservation Bill

Updated: The House on Monday passed Senate Bill 201 without any debate, and without Sen. John Whitmire's amendment to prohibit smoking on Capitol grounds. The bill addresses the functions of the State Preservation Board, the agency charged with preserving and maintaining the Capitol. Whitmire has said he will fight for his amendment when the two chambers reconcile differences in a conference committee. 

"I've been raising hell about it for several years now," Whitmire said upon learning his amendment did not make it out of the House Committee on Culture, Recreation and Tourism last month. This is the first time he's filed a formal measure seeking to end smoking at the capitol. "I've gotten a little more creative this session," he said. 

Whitmire said he quit smoking in 1981 and "can't stand it now."

Original story: State Sen. John Whitmire, D-Houston, told his colleagues on Thursday that he remembers when every desk in both Capitol chambers had an ashtray. Some 40 years later, the dean of the Senate pushed through an amendment that would abolish smoking on the Capitol grounds altogether. 

"This is speaking to secondary smoke for our school children, our workers," Whitmire said. "That's what progress and education and smart rules are about."

Whitmire added the amendment on Thursday to Senate Bill 201. Authored by Sen. Brian Birdwell, R-Granbury, the bill addresses the functions of the State Preservation Board, the agency tasked with preserving and maintaining the Capitol.

Whitmire's proposal, which must still make it through the House, would prohibit smoking inside the Capitol gates. Offenders would face a Class C Misdemeanor and be subject to a $500 fine.

Birdwell was hesitant to accept Whitmire's amendment. He said enforcing a smoking ban on Capitol grounds would consume Department of Public Safety officers' time and leave them less focused on security.

But more than one senator shared stories of having to walk through a hazy cloud of cigarette smoke on their walk into the building.

"It's just a nuisance that we shouldn't have to deal with because they actually take over the staircase and the open air space in the annex," Whitmire said.

Sen. Robert Duncan, R-Lubbock, acknowledged the problem, but expressed concern about criminalizing the habit. Currently, it's a Class C Misdemeanor to smoke on school grounds. Whitmire's amendment mirrors that offense.

He said he is confident that DPS would use good judgment, likely opting to issue warnings to first-time offenders.

In a floor debate that lasted no more than 20 minutes, Sen. Joan Huffman, R-Southside Place, complimented her Democratic colleague and his "conservative approach" to addressing a smoking ban with local control.

“I believe that this is the ultimate local control in that those of us who work here in this building and on these grounds and who represent the folks are the ones making the decision," Huffman said.

If the measure is approved and the governor signs off on it, Whitmire said he doesn't think it will take long for people to adjust to the ban. "People would just know the grounds are not for smoking," he said. "They're sacred areas. We want our guests and our workers to be as healthy as possible."

Texas Tribune donors or members may be quoted or mentioned in our stories, or may be the subject of them. For a complete list of contributors, click here.